The Best New York Betting Sites to Gamble with Online in 2024
It’s been a long time coming, but the Empire State finally is home to legal online betting. So, which New York betting sites are the best? We tested, rated, and ranked all the legal options according to various criteria, like their odds and payouts, bonus offers, and apps. Here’s how they fared:
| Best Betting Sites in The United States | Bonus Offers | Highlights | Rating | Secure Link | T&Cs |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Top 2 New York Betting Sites
- 🥇 Caesars Sportsbook ✪ Best NY Sportsbook Overall
- 🥈 BetMGM ✪ Best for NHL
When you’re searching for a new NY sportsbook, it helps to break the best options down by areas in which they excel. It does you no good as a basketball bettor to register with a site catering primarily to football handicappers. Here are the best NY betting sites by category:
| 🏆 Best Betting Site in New York | Caesars Sportsbook |
| 🔍Top New Site in New York | BetMGM |
| 🎁 Best for Bonuses | Caesars Sportsbook |
| 📱 Top App | BetMGM |
| 📺 Best for Live Betting | Caesars Sportsbook |
| 📈 Highest Payout Betting Site | BetMGM |
| 💳 Best Payment Options | Caesars Sportsbook |
| 🛡️ Safest Betting Site | BetMGM |
| 🏈 Best NFL Betting Website | Caesars Sportsbook |
| ✨ Top for Extra Features | BetMGM |
As you can see, the New York sports betting options listed here all have areas in which they are superior to the competition. Expert bettors know how to use this to their advantage, and they shop around the top options in specific categories to find the best odds available.
New York Online Betting Sites List: All Legal New York Online Sportsbooks
We tested all the online sportsbooks NY has to offer and collated them into the list below with their parent companies and license status. We only list legal NY betting sites on this page, so you know all the options mentioned here are legitimate.
- American Wagering, Inc – (Caesars Sportsbook) – Licensed: Yes
- BetMGM, LLC – (BetMGM) – Licensed: Yes
When you start searching for the best online New York sportsbook, be sure to keep an eye out for licensing information. You can see the New York State Gambling Commission’s (NYSGC) list of approved operators for a complete rundown of legal betting sites.
How to Start Betting Online in New York
To get started betting online in New York, choose a sportsbook from the table on this page. After you make your selection, the steps are the same at all the sites. Here’s how to get started with the best betting sites NY has to offer:
Choose a site from our list of the best NY sportsbooks and follow the instructions for opening an account. Be sure to choose one that fits your preferences.
Choose one of the payment methods accepted at NY sportsbooks to fund your account with. Make sure you can afford to lose what you put in.
Look through the markets, and consider the payouts for your chosen wagers. Once you make your selections and decide how much to wager, click the “Bet” button.
The steps really are that simple. Once you get used to it, you can complete the entire process in less than five minutes. Consider shopping around the New York online sports betting operators listed here to find the best odds for your desired markets before you create your account.
How We Picked the Best NY Betting Sites
To make our list of the best betting sites New York players can use, we considered several criteria. First and foremost, we examine each operator’s safety record. Luckily, bettors gambling in regulated states like New York have legal recourse if disputes arise.
Legality is our primary concern because all licensed New York betting sites are routinely checked and scrutinized by the NYSGC. If there are ever disputes, it steps in and conducts investigations, and charges NY sportsbooks hefty fines for breaking rules and regulations.
Staying Safe and Legal
Safety at legal New York betting sites is enforced by the NYSGC, which makes New York online sportsbooks follow strict security rules to maintain their licenses. One of the primary safety checks all betting sites NY gamblers can use implement is the Know Your Customer (KYC) protocol.
KYC protocol is when a New York online sportsbook requests documents confirming your identity. This prevents others from making transactions in your name without your consent. Additionally, all the betting sites New York gives licenses to must implement anti-money laundering (AML) procedures.
Although it can be frustrating when your account is flagged for a KYC or AML check, it’s a necessary part of the sports betting experience. At the end of the day, these New York sportsbook regulations are designed with your safety and security in mind.
Laws and Licenses
In November 2021, the NYSGC approved nine mobile sports wagering operator licenses after a hotly contested bidding process. The limited number of licenses available means some big names wouldn’t make the cut, most notably bet365.
A license from the NYSGC grants online sports betting providers the ability to operate legally in New York. If you come across a NY sports betting site taking bets without the proper license, it’s best to stay away as it’s operating illegally and any wagers you make are illegal.
You can read the official NYSGC gambling law page for the complete rules and regulations pertaining to online sports betting in New York. We recommend skimming through them to make sure you’re aware of what is and isn’t allowed so you can stay away from illegal bookies.
To find out if a NY online sports betting operator has a license, you can visit the NYSGC website, look in the website’s footer, or read through the betting site’s terms and conditions. If you can’t find information about it in any of those places, it’s likely a black market sportsbook.
Taxes
Another reason to choose from our list of the best NY betting sites is that they pay 51% of their gross betting income to the Empire State as part of their licensing agreements.
Therefore, a majority of the money gambled goes back into the state’s coffers and is distributed through programs relying on tax revenue. Taxation was also a big factor in the NYSGC determining which sportsbooks got licenses, as each applicant had to list a preferred tax rate.
Individuals must also pay taxes on gambling winnings. Federally, the amount is 24% of your net gambling income. If you win over $5,000 in a year you will be subject to automatic withholding. We suggest reading the IRS gambling guidelines for a full overview of how it works.
On a state level, if you’re a winner with NY online sports betting sites the amount you pay varies by your annual income and your tax bracket. Gambling winnings can put you into a higher tax bracket when they’re added to your yearly income.
Gambling taxes are paid as part of your state income tax. However, Big Apple residents owe an additional 3.876% as New York City collects its own income tax. This is something to consider if you’re an NYC resident searching for the best New York sportsbook to fit your tastes.
Data Security & Encryption
Something to pay close attention to when you’re choosing sites for online sports betting New Yorkers can use is their encryption level. When you gamble with one of the best NY sportsbooks on our list, some of the world’s top cybersecurity firms are protecting your data.
It’s worth investigating a site’s encryption level for yourself. Legitimate sites mention their encryption levels in their privacy policies or general terms. In general, the higher the encryption, the more secure your transactions are and the harder it is for unauthorized parties to access your information.
Alongside transaction encryption, a New York betting site’s web security certificate plays an important role in keeping you safe. Several highly-respected, household-name brands like GoDaddy, Amazon Web Services (AWS), and Cloudflare verify sportsbooks’ security levels and grant them certificates.
To view a website’s security certificate, simply click on the padlock on the left-hand side of your browser’s address bar. Click on the button to view the certificate, and you can see which company certifies the site. If you have any doubts about the legitimacy of a web security certificate, simply visit the certifying company’s website. This helps you deduce its authenticity for yourself.
Minimum Legal Age
The minimum legal age for New York online sports betting is 21 like it is in most other states. While somewhat strict, it’s necessary to prevent underage gambling, especially by those under 18 years old.
If you suspect someone to be gambling underage or facilitating underage gambling, reach out to one of the responsible gambling organizations mentioned in the following section. They will provide you with advice on potential next steps. Remember, many people have this affliction, and there is no shame in admitting that you have a problem.
Responsible Gambling
The biggest issue surrounding the legalization of sites for online sports betting New York gamblers could use was responsible gambling initiatives. To make this page as one of the best NY betting sites, an operator must participate in the state’s self-exclusion program.
On top of this, licensed NY online sports betting sites should, under state law, refuse service to those identified as problem gamblers. If you or someone you know is showing the signs of a gambling problem, reach out to the New York Council on Problem Gambling for help.
Certificates
Certificates displayed in the footers of sites for sports betting NY gamblers can use demonstrate trust. The best NY sports betting operators have several of these certificates from payment providers, web security firms, and responsible gambling organizations.
- NYSGC – Gambling Authority & Licensing Body
- SSL Certificate – Financial Transaction Encryption
- Web Security Certificate – Data Protection & Security
- New York Council on Problem Gambling – Responsible Gaming Initiative
- Trusted Payment Methods – Vendor Certification
In general, NY sportsbooks with more certificates tend to be more trustworthy. New York sports betting apps and sites go through routine checks by various third parties to ensure they are safe, secure, and legal. Simply scroll to the bottom of any NY sports betting website to see all the certificates it owns.
Bonuses & Offers
The main method the best New York betting sites use to acquire new customers is the welcome offer. These promotional deals are available for new sign-ups who are depositing for the first time. Keep an eye out, because some sites require promo codes.
The table below shows the best New York betting sites’ offers. Though often advertised as free, they require something from you to kick in – like making a deposit or meeting a certain threshold for the amount you wager within a certain period.
| New York Betting Site | Welcome Bonus | Deposit Features | Rating | Secure Link | T&C’s |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🥇 Caesars Sportsbook | Bet $50 Get $250 | 1x, 7 days, -10,000 | Visit Site! | Full T&Cs Apply! New customer offer. Please gamble responsibly. 21+ | |
| 🥈 BetMGM | Top Odds | –, N/A, – | Visit Site! | T&Cs Apply. New customer offer. Always gamble responsibly. 21+ |
Other common terms and conditions you’ll find included with bonuses for online sports betting New York gamblers can claim are validity periods, minimum odds requirements, and playthrough amounts. That’s why we always suggest reading the promotional terms for any New York betting sites you’re considering opening an account with.
Average Payout, Odds and Lines at New York Sportsbooks
Almost all of us get started with online sports betting for the same reason. However, very few sports bettors end up turning a reliable profit. One of the reasons for this is they don’t shop around for the best odds on the bets they want to make.
This crucial step is one of the easiest ways to keep your bankroll healthy. The best online New York betting sites all have decent average payout levels, but odds on specific events and outcomes can vary wildly. Here are the average payout rates at the best New York betting sites:
- Caesars Sportsbook – 94.88% Payout Rate
Even though a NY sportsbook may appear on this list, you’re not guaranteed the best odds all the time. That’s because markets fluctuate over time as more money is gambled and lines become more accurate. The nearer the start of a game e.g. for MLS betting, the more information is available – and sportsbooks adjust for this fact.
At the end of the day though, betting sites adjust their odds so their liabilities are equal across the outcomes for a specific market. If there is a large amount of money bet at one sportsbook, chances are the others haven’t adjusted their lines yet, and you can still get a good price.
That’s the importance of shopping around. When you find the best lines, you are increasing the likelihood that your chosen wager contains value, which when found consistently, increases your bankroll. That’s why it’s worth opening accounts with several sportsbooks and comparing their lines for each bet you make.
Live Betting Sites in New York
A new, highly popular way to bet on sports is through live betting sites. This recent development in the gambling world lets you wager on sporting events after they start. So if you think you’re smarter than a football coach, you can bet on the outcome of the next Giants, Jets, or Bills play.
Another common live betting method is hedging. You can bet against your pregame wagers to limit your losses when they don’t work out, or find arbitrage opportunities (guaranteed wins) when underdogs go ahead early. This is very difficult to execute properly, so it’s best left to more advanced handicappers.
Best Live Betting Bonus
- Bonus Code: N/A
- Minimum Odds: -10,000
- Wagering requirement: 1x
- Validity: 7 days
Welcome Bonus
Ongoing Offers Parlay Profit Boost
Live Promotions Live Profit Boost
-
Full T&Cs Apply! New customer offer. Please gamble responsibly. 21+
The primary benefit of live betting sites New York gamblers can use is that you can still wager on the game if you aren’t able to before the game starts. You can still find the same or similar odds for a few minutes after the game starts, and you get to see the early portion of the game play out.
Another way to get a wager down on an in-progress game is through half, quarter, or period betting. If you see a team is being dominant in the first half, you can predict whether that trend continues or if they let their foot off the gas.
This feature is available at all legal New York betting sites and New York sports betting apps. The capability is enabled through up-to-the-second stats streams and lightning-fast data connections. In our opinion, it’s the ultimate sports gambling experience, and can turn even the most boring games into nail biters.
Payments
Payment methods are another differentiator between the best New York sports betting operators and the pretenders. You want to find betting sites accepting of your preferred payment option so that you aren’t forced to set up new accounts with unfamiliar providers.
Luckily, many of the top New York betting sites online accept all the major credit and debit card providers, which is the standard form of payment for online gambling in the United States. However, you do have other options, like PayPal, PayNearMe, and bank transfer.
| Payment Method | Type | Deposit Limits | Deposit/Withdrawal | Payment Fee |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Trustly | eWallet | $10 – $50,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Visa | Debit Card / Credit Card | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Mastercard | Debit Card / Credit Card | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| PayPal | eWallet | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Bank Transfer | Online Banking | $100 – $100,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Discover | Credit Card | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Not Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| American Express | Credit Card | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Not Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Electronic Gift Card | Prepaid | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Not Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| PayNearMe | eWallet | $5 – $500 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| eCheck | Online Banking | $50 – $100,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Online Banking | Online Banking | $5 – $100,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
| Play+ | Prepaid Card | $5 – $20,000 | Available for Deposits / Available for Withdrawals | No Fees |
One of the best reasons to use PayPal sites is that the payment provider acts as a middle man between your bank and the sportsbook. That way you don’t have to share your bank account or card number over the internet.
Ultimately, the best sportsbooks New York has to offer on this page have an immense amount of security, so banking transactions at sportsbooks are completely safe. However, we do appreciate that some people like to be extra careful.
Best Payment Methods
We prefer eWallets for our betting endeavors. The reason for this is that you can manage all of your cards and accounts with one eWallet. The best eWallet in our opinion is PayPal, which is accepted at most of the best sportsbooks NY has to offer.
If PayPal isn’t your thing, you can always use plastic options like Visa, Mastercard, or American Express. The payment methods for online sports betting New York gamblers can use are all well-known, reputable, highly-secure options, so you can’t go wrong with any of them.
The Top New York Sports Betting App
Given the hustle and bustle often associated with the Empire State, it makes sense that most New York betting sites offer standalone apps. The top New York sports betting apps are available both for instant play and download through app stores, and are both iOS and Android compatible.
To be considered for our best New York sports betting apps, an offering needs to have the same or better functionality than its desktop version. While this may seem simple in theory, all too often we come across betting apps that are slow or clunky.
Furthermore, our best NY sports betting app performed the same in its instant-play format as it did in its native application. We tested it on both Android and iOS smartphones and tablets, and our desktop computers. In the end, it stood out as the top NY sports betting app.
Customer Service
A quality most bettors are guilty of overlooking is a betting site’s customer service. It’s one of those things you never think about until you need it, but when you do, you want the highest quality available. Luckily, we tested the customer service teams at all the top New York betting sites for you.
All the betting sites listed on this page have several contact options, excellent live chat capabilities, and fast response times. In the end, if something goes wrong, the customer service team will be an important part of your overall experience at online betting sites.
Lastly, if you ever have a serious payment issue, fear your identity has been compromised, or are having issues controlling your gambling, you can reach out to the customer support teams at the best sportsbooks New York has to offer at any time during opening hours.
New Betting Sites in New York
Since mobile sports wagering was recently legalized, there are plenty of new betting sites in New York to choose from. But just because they’re new here doesn’t mean they haven’t been around the block. Here are the top options we found while researching for our write-up:
| New NY Betting Site | Bonus Offer | Active from | Rating | Secure Link | T&C’s |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Caesars Sportsbook | Bet $50 Get $250 | 2022 | Visit Site! | Full T&Cs Apply! New customer offer. Please gamble responsibly. 21+ | |
| BetMGM | Top Odds | 2022 | Visit Site! | T&Cs Apply. New customer offer. Always gamble responsibly. 21+ |
All of the new NY betting sites are well-recognized brands in the sports betting world. The benefit of this is you know what you’re getting. Even though these sites recently launched in New York, we have plenty of experience gambling with them in other states and their products are second to none.
Because the NYSGC could only distribute a small number of licenses, it may be a while before there are any new options for sports betting New York gamblers can use. However, we plan to stay on top of this developing market and we will update our table when new sportsbooks go live.
Illegal Betting Sites in New York
With so many legal betting sites in New York, it doesn’t make sense to play with unlicensed operators. Though many advertise themselves as licensed, usually through Curacao or other international authorities, they do not meet the requirements for accepting New York bettors. Here’s a list of known black market sportsbooks in NY:
- ⛔ My Bookie
- ⛔ BetDSI
- ⛔ 5Dimes
- ⛔ Bovada
- ⛔ 1XBet
- ⛔ 22Bet
- ⛔ BetOnline.ag
- ⛔ BetUS
- ⛔ Bookmaker EU
- ⛔ Bigbetworld
- ⛔ Gamebet
- ⛔ 12BET
There are several reasons to avoid illegal bookmakers, but the primary one is to protect your sensitive data. If something goes wrong, you have no legal recourse – something the NYSGC provides with licensed operators. Lastly, unlicensed sportsbooks don’t pay the 51% tax that legal ones do.
The History of New York’s Gambling Industry
New York has a long history with gambling. In the 1800s, it was one of the only places in the country where you could legally participate in lotteries until they were banned in the middle of the century. It launched a state lottery in 1967 that remains hugely successful.
During the early and mid-1900s, the state had a big problem with the mafia and illegal gambling. Organized crime was rampant in New York City specifically and the mob funded its activities through illegal sportsbooks, numbers games, and speakeasy casinos.
Off-track horse racing betting was approved in 1970. The logic was to put an end to illegal bookmakers that were capitalizing on New Yorkers’ collective desire for action. This also gave rise to the first video streaming services in 1984, which finally let bettors watch the races live.
Finally, after the repeal of the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA) in 2018, New York betting websites were a possibility. State bill S.2509C signed by former Gov. Andrew Cuomo in 2020 meant that legal sportsbooks would finally come to New York.
Frequently Asked Questions
While we tried to make our guide to New York betting sites as comprehensive as possible, our readers occasionally have more specific questions which you can find the answers to below. If you have any additional questions, comments, or concerns, feel free to reach out to us at info@bestbettingsites.com.
🥇 What is the best betting site in New York?
The best betting site in New York will vary by person. Each gambler has a unique style and preferences, so it's important to consider your risk tolerance, the markets you want to bet on, and your gambling style when evaluating your options.
🔎 Are there any new betting sites in NY?
Since mobile sports wagering is relatively new in the Empire State, there are plenty of new betting sites in NY to choose from. You can see our list of the best new NY betting sites for some great selections.
📜 Is there a list of New York betting sites?
Yes, we created a list of New York betting sites so you can see what your options are. We also included all the relevant information about each one's licensing and ownership group.
🛡️ Are NY betting sites safe?
Yes, NY betting sites are safe. Each licensed operator must go through routine checks from the NYSGC to make sure they're meeting security standards. See our write up on safety at NY sportsbooks for a full overview of what to look out for.
💵 How does New York make money from betting sites?
New York makes money from betting sites through tax revenue. Each operator pays 51% of its gross betting revenues to the state as part of its licensing agreement. Additionally, net winnings are taxed from individuals on state income tax returns. Here is a guide to gambling taxes in New York.
⚖️ Is online betting in NY also legal?
Yes, online betting in NY is now 100% legal. You can read more about New York gambling law for a rundown of the rules and regulations.
👮 How can I solve a dispute with a New York online sportsbook?
The NYSGC handles all disputes between sportsbooks and individual bettors. Your first step should be attempting to resolve it through discussions with your NY betting site customer support team before escalating a complaint to the NYSGC.
New York Betting Sites – Build Your Gambling Empire
The long-awaited launch of online sports betting in the Empire State means New Yorkers can get in on the action straight away. No longer is it a necessity to travel across the Hudson to access a legal New Jersey sportsbook for a wager.
If you’re still not convinced about the safety and security of New York betting sites, or you simply feel like a gambling getaway, check out our article on US betting sites where you can find a list of all the legal sports betting states.